AirNav Radar
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

Login with username, password and session length
 


Author Topic: ADS-B Heathrow arrivals currently powered by RadarBox  (Read 10145 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

DaveReid

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1815
    • Heathrow last 100 ADS-B arrivals
ADS-B Heathrow arrivals currently powered by RadarBox
« on: May 13, 2010, 11:44:16 AM »
For those who take an interest in such things, my EGLL arrivals website is currently being powered by RadarBox, while its SBS-1 predecessor is away being used on more esoteric projects.

Initial indications are that there is no detectable difference in the output - feel free to visit at www.civilaircraftregisters.org/Mode_S_Resources/LogReport/EGLLADSB.asp.

Enjoy !
This post has been scanned for any traces of negativity, bias, sarcasm and general anti-social behaviour

DaveReid

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1815
    • Heathrow last 100 ADS-B arrivals
Re: ADS-B Heathrow arrivals currently powered by RadarBox
« Reply #1 on: May 13, 2010, 10:51:20 PM »
Initial indications are that there is no detectable difference in the output

Uh oh, it would appear I spoke too soon !

Since hooking RB up to the EGLL web server I've started to see anomalies like a Final Alt of 38000' for an aircraft on the LHR ILS.

After doing a bit of troubleshooting, it appears these are instances of the previously-reported bug where RadarBox gets confused between two aircraft with similar hex codes.

For example, here's an extract from the RBL log showing G-EUUL/4009D9 inbound on the BAW501 earlier today:

$PTA,20100513123850654,4009D9,,1800,,,,,51.4781,-0.2946,,
$PTA,20100513123850654,4009D9,,1800,163.0,269.6,-768,,51.4781,-0.2934,,
$PTA,20100513123850654,4009D9,,1825,,,,,51.4781,-0.2922,,
$PTA,20100513123854791,4009D9,,1725,164.0,269.3,-1088,,51.4780,-0.3012,,
$PTA,20100513123854791,4009D9,,1750,164.0,269.7,-896,,51.4780,-0.2977,,
$PTA,20100513123858910,4009D9,,1650,,,,,51.4780,-0.3024,,
$PTA,20100513123858910,4009D9,,1650,164.0,269.3,-896,,51.4780,-0.3036,,
$PTA,20100513123903039,4009D9,,1600,162.0,270.0,-768,,51.4780,-0.3108,7474,
$PTA,20100513123903039,4009D9,,1600,162.0,270.0,-896,,51.4780,-0.3098,,
$PTA,20100513123903039,4009D9,,1625,163.0,269.3,-768,,51.4780,-0.3087,,
$PTA,20100513123907170,4009D9,,1550,162.0,270.0,-1024,,51.4780,-0.3147,,
$PTA,20100513123907170,4009D9,,1575,,,,,51.4780,-0.3134,,
$PTA,20100513123911293,4009D9,BAW501,1500,161.0,270.4,-960,,51.4780,-0.3168,,
$PTA,20100513123915421,4009D9,,1450,,,,,51.4780,-0.3248,,
$PTA,20100513123915421,4009D9,,1450,152.0,270.0,-448,,51.4780,-0.3236,,
$PTA,20100513123919554,4009D9,,1425,146.0,269.2,-768,,51.4780,-0.3278,,
$PTA,20100513123923679,4009D9,,1350,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513123927810,4009D9,,1300,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124347567,4009DD,,38000,446.4,15.6,0,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124404066,4009D9,,38000,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124408102,4009DD,,38000,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124412131,4009DD,,38000,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124416165,4009DD,,38000,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124420207,4009DD,,38000,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124424333,4009DD,,38000,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124428392,4009DD,,38000,446.4,15.6,0,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124432435,4009D9,,38000,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124432435,4009DD,TOM9HP,38000,446.2,15.5,0,,51.2292,-0.7585,5353,
$PTA,20100513124436474,4009DD,TOM9HP,38000,,,,,51.2330,-0.7568,,
$PTA,20100513124440525,4009D9,,37975,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124440525,4009DD,,38000,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124444586,4009D9,,38000,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124444586,4009DD,,38000,446.2,15.5,0,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124448635,4009DD,,38000,446.2,15.5,0,,51.2610,-0.7445,5353,
$PTA,20100513124448635,4009DD,TOM9HP,38000,,,,,51.2628,-0.7437,5353,
$PTA,20100513124452676,4009DD,,38000,,,,,51.2651,-0.7426,,
$PTA,20100513124452676,4009DD,,38000,,,,,51.2709,-0.7401,,
$PTA,20100513124452676,4009DD,,38000,446.2,15.5,0,,51.2671,-0.7417,5353,
$PTA,20100513124456732,4009D9,,38000,,,,,,,,
$PTA,20100513124456732,4009DD,,38000,,,,,51.2727,-0.7393,,

The log lines in red clearly belong to G-OOBC/4009DD, which was airborne at that time, and not to 4009D9, which was safely on the ground at LHR by 1244z.

So, whereas previously the bug was only though to affect callsigns being shown against the wrong aircraft, it now appears that navigation info is also being wrongly assigned.  RB has been similarly confused today with 4009D8/400CD8 and 4008E5/4008F1, so it's certainly not just a one-off.

AirNav, is there any progress on a fix for this ? 

Frankly, it's a PITA not being able to use RadarBox as a substitute while my SBS-1 is otherwise engaged, as I'd hoped - in fact I've had to take the LHR website offline for the time being - not a good advert for RadarBox !
This post has been scanned for any traces of negativity, bias, sarcasm and general anti-social behaviour

DaveReid

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1815
    • Heathrow last 100 ADS-B arrivals
Re: ADS-B Heathrow arrivals currently powered by RadarBox
« Reply #2 on: May 15, 2010, 06:24:09 PM »
AirNav, is there any progress on a fix for this ?

Well ?

While I appreciate that helping me to get my LHR website to work properly with RadarBox isn't a priority for you (though that would be nice), I would have thought that it was in the interest of all users that you (a) acknowledge and (b) fix the "hex code confusion" bug.

If it helps, I can provide a list of all the hex code pairs that I encountered where details belonging to one aircraft were wrongly assigned to another.  In fact the LHR arrivals scenario is an ideal one for diagnosing the problem, since clearly an aircraft can't be on the ground and at FL380 at the same time.
This post has been scanned for any traces of negativity, bias, sarcasm and general anti-social behaviour