AirNav Systems Forum

AirNav RadarBox and RadarBox24.com => AirNav RadarBox and RadarBox24.com Discussion => Topic started by: vic_atc on November 07, 2009, 05:44:15 PM

Title: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: vic_atc on November 07, 2009, 05:44:15 PM
Hi,

I'm encountering something very unusual. I have no problem with the reception of my radarbox. My RB detects planes at aprox 230 nmi away. However, I've noticed something very weird: every plane that enters a circle around my radarbox (a cricle with aprox 10 km radius), it simply cannot be seen. Immediately after these planes exits this imaginary circle, the radarbox starts seeing them again. I have checked that there is nothing wrong configured on my Radarbox Software (like not showing the aircraft within a specific range). It simply doesn't receive the Mode S signal anymore for those planes being inside this "blind zone".
Have you seen this strange behavior too? Is there something wrong with my RB?
I can expect that this behavior could be due to:
1. Very strong signal. It saturates the LNA of the Radarbox.
2. Omnidirectional characteristic of the aircraft's transponder antenna. Thus, when the plane is above my head the signal would be very low.
3. Maybe the Doppler effect. Firstly, the plane is heading toward my radarbox so the signal's frequency is bigger: f_central + f_doppler. When it goes away, the frequency will rapidly decreases to f_central - f_doppler. Maybe the radarbox cannot adapt to this fast frequency changing.

If there is anyone who can explain me what is happening, I would be very grateful.

Regards!
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: RodBearden on November 07, 2009, 06:01:02 PM
Hi Vic

I reckon your point 2 is the answer - combine that with the fact that your aerial will be pointing straight at the transmitter, with no "length" showing.

It's probably not being overpowered - I quite often have a police helicopter hovering a few hundred metres from my location but not above it, and the reception (admittedly only of Mode-S) is fine.

Rod
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Jeremy on November 07, 2009, 06:01:26 PM
Are the a/c your are seeing outside your blind zone on the network?
J.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 07, 2009, 06:03:42 PM
What antenna are you using?

Generally a colinear antenna like the supplied antenna will have a null along the axis of the antenna, as will the blade antennas on the aircraft.

When these nulls are aligned it can lead to a big increase in path loss and hence not enough signal received to decode.

Also note that the transponder antennas on the top of the aircraft are partially shielded by the aircraft structure when seen from below, so a similar effect applies even if there is no null in the antenna radiation pattern.

Do you see any aircraft at low altitudes over your location? In theory these should be received better than if they are at high altitude.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: vic_atc on November 07, 2009, 06:20:31 PM
Hi,

To Rod: many thanks for the answer. I should expect that everyone has observed this behavior, am I right? If not... I agree that the signals for the plane right above my head are weaker, but I suspect that RB should still receive them. So, I'm not very confident that my RB is working properly. If everybody tells me that this is the normal behavior observed on all the RB units (using the provided antenna), I'll be ok.

Are the a/c your are seeing outside your blind zone on the network?
J.

Hi Jeremy,

No. I have disabled the network feature.

To Fenris:

Actually I'm very close to an airport so I'm not very sure that the pilot enables the ADS-B feature of the Mode S right after the plane takes off. Today, two airplanes have flown right over my head (in Climbing state) but I couldn't see them on the Radarbox Map. Probably they were listed in the left panel but I've missed to check that out. I repeat, I guess they didn't had the ADS-B enabled.
Otherwise, the most of the planes for which I'm reporting this problem were flying at cruising altitude, right over my head. That's way you and Rod are probably right.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 07, 2009, 06:24:42 PM
Do you know what aircraft they were that passed low overhead? Do you see aircraft on the ground? How close is the airport?

Most aircraft that transmit ADS-B do so all the time, on the ground too.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: vic_atc on November 07, 2009, 06:34:20 PM
Do you know what aircraft they were that passed low overhead? Do you see aircraft on the ground? How close is the airport?

Most aircraft that transmit ADS-B do so all the time, on the ground too.

They were both B738s. Of course they have Mode -S with ADS-B. I was able to see them on the map 1-2 minutes after they've flown over my RB's antenna.

Regarding the airport: 2 weeks ago I went with my car near the airport (200-300 m). I wasn't able to see any 'ground' plane on the Radarbox software. Only after 10 minutes after taking off. Or 10 minutes before landing.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 07, 2009, 06:39:11 PM
Hmm, are you sure you don't have some sort of filter applied? An altitude one perhaps?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: MikeC on November 07, 2009, 07:37:06 PM
I don't suffer from this problem using a GP-1090 external antenna:
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: palmar on November 07, 2009, 08:34:14 PM
Quote
Also note that the transponder antennas on the top of the aircraft are partially shielded by the aircraft structure when seen from below, so a similar effect applies even if there is no null in the antenna radiation pattern.

SSR, Mode-S and TCAS use two antennas, top and bottom of fuselage.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: palmar on November 07, 2009, 08:37:44 PM
Quote
3. Maybe the Doppler effect. Firstly, the plane is heading toward my radarbox so the signal's frequency is bigger: f_central + f_doppler. When it goes away, the frequency will rapidly decreases to f_central - f_doppler. Maybe the radarbox cannot adapt to this fast frequency changing.

No issue. The input stage is broadband (more than necessary so it picks up DME signals) and signals will not be lost by Doppler shift.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: palmar on November 07, 2009, 08:39:45 PM
Quote
Regarding the airport: 2 weeks ago I went with my car near the airport (200-300 m). I wasn't able to see any 'ground' plane on the Radarbox software. Only after 10 minutes after taking off. Or 10 minutes before landing.

If you have seen the same aircraft while en-route but not while landing or becoming airborne, something is definitely wrong. ADS-B is not switched on by pilots, it remains on on the ground. EXCEPTION: if you are in Singapore.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: vic_atc on November 07, 2009, 09:35:32 PM
Hi,

I've just come back from the airport :) For the low level flights (app / dep) this is what really happens:

- The tracking stops 10 min before landing. But messages are still received (at 'Changed' i can see that it changes every second). I also could see planes with 'Grounded' status. But no position report.
- Something like that happens for departing planes. Only after 10 minutes they show up on the map. Until then, only basic Mode-S info.

I have triple checked that no filter was applied. No Range/Altitude filter.

There will be a long night because right now I'm going under a pretty busy route to check again what happens when I'm right under the plane. I'll send updates, I'm taking my wireless modem with me.

Regards.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 07, 2009, 09:59:31 PM
Quote
Also note that the transponder antennas on the top of the aircraft are partially shielded by the aircraft structure when seen from below, so a similar effect applies even if there is no null in the antenna radiation pattern.

SSR, Mode-S and TCAS use two antennas, top and bottom of fuselage.

Yes, the top antenna behaves differently from the bottom antenna, it has even less coverage below the aircraft.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: palmar on November 07, 2009, 10:29:32 PM
Hi,

I've just come back from the airport :) For the low level flights (app / dep) this is what really happens:

- The tracking stops 10 min before landing. But messages are still received (at 'Changed' i can see that it changes every second). I also could see planes with 'Grounded' status. But no position report.
- Something like that happens for departing planes. Only after 10 minutes they show up on the map. Until then, only basic Mode-S info.

I have triple checked that no filter was applied. No Range/Altitude filter.

There will be a long night because right now I'm going under a pretty busy route to check again what happens when I'm right under the plane. I'll send updates, I'm taking my wireless modem with me.

Regards.

If you are not in Singapore from where the same behaivour was reported before:
Your box may not be able to detect 112 bit Mode-S signals when a certain reception power is exceeded. It seems that 56 bit signals still come through. There is a floating reference detector which may not work properly for 112 bit. I would think it is best to return the box.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 07, 2009, 11:29:54 PM
SSR, Mode-S and TCAS use two antennas, top and bottom of fuselage.

And ADS-B position squitters are sent twice per second, alternately from the top and bottom antennae.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: vic_atc on November 08, 2009, 01:42:59 PM
If you are not in Singapore from where the same behaivour was reported before:
Your box may not be able to detect 112 bit Mode-S signals when a certain reception power is exceeded. It seems that 56 bit signals still come through. There is a floating reference detector which may not work properly for 112 bit. I would think it is best to return the box.

Yes, that could be a good explanation. I'm from Romania and unfortunately there are only a few guys who own a RB. Personally, I know only one person. I asked him to make some tests together near the airport and to compare the devices.
Yesterday night I've made a trip right under a very busy route and I was able to see 2 planes flying over the radarbox (only 2 planes have flown on this 'busy' route while I was there :) ). The tests performed until yesterday always took place in a single location. Yesterday was the first time when I changed this position. Maybe there is an interference in the first location .. or I don't know.
But this doesn't explain why I can't see the app/dep planes when I'm located near the airport.

Regards
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: puddy on November 09, 2009, 02:11:39 PM
I have the same issue, I thought it was because the airspace around me is closed military airspace.

I can see the planes visually they dont show up within a 10 miles radius on my radar box.

I had thought it was my aerial apart from this issue I have no other problems

I wanted to track a plane to spain today but the network been down
I am based near Boston (UK)

Puddy
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: MikeC on November 09, 2009, 05:02:08 PM
I tried an experiment, swapping the external antenna for a magmount for the ANRB.

I used my SBS-1e magmount as I've misplaced the ANRB one.

As can be seen. the AirFrance showed up within the approx 10 nm radius on both Basetation and the RB.  But then the aircraft started to lag a bit on the RB screen, though it caught up again when it was well past my 10 nm radius.

The side-by-side screenshots were taken simultaneously.

Not conclusive, but I wish I had an ANRB magmount to try.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Runway 31 on November 09, 2009, 05:08:01 PM
Plenty of aircraft fly over my house each day inbound Glasgow and outbound Edinburgh as well as high level fly overs and I see them all the way over the house with no gaps.

I am however using a different loft mounted antenna but never had any problems when using the Airnav supplied one.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: MikeC on November 09, 2009, 05:14:01 PM
I had no problems when both boxes were sharing the external antenna.  I was just trying to test if the supplied one was an issue.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: t1mb0 on November 09, 2009, 06:36:40 PM
Hi

got bored reading the many fanciful explanations.
Vertically mounted antenna, ie pointing up/down produce greatest 'gain' in the horizontal plane, and practically nothing straight up/down, so maximising your range towards the horizon.
I reckon if you place the antenna on its side, you'll get uninterupted coverage over the top, but you won't get much range(well you might, but it will be perpendicular to the axis of the antenna)
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: palmar on November 09, 2009, 08:43:40 PM
The thread was originally talking about low flying airplanes (approaches, departures seen from the airport fence) within 10 miles or airplanes on the ground. While I agree that antennae may have a blind spot right above them this would not be an issue for this kind of traffic.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: tarbat on November 09, 2009, 11:29:42 PM
Not conclusive, but I wish I had an ANRB magmount to try.

Didn't you get one supplied in the box?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Hawkeye on November 10, 2009, 03:35:48 PM
Ref Reply #21
A bit of a strange first line methinks.
The RB antenna supplied is quite capable of picking up aircraft overhead (see attach).
Unfortunately I am not knowledgeable enough to put forward a suggestion as to the cause of vic-atc's problem, but the explanation put forward as conclusive in this reply is clearly not the answer.
The always helpful members of this group have put forward various suggestions to try to solve the problem. That is how this forum works and generally someone will come up with a solution sooner or later, 'fanciful' or not.

Syd



Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: vic_atc on November 10, 2009, 08:32:08 PM
Good evening,

Thanks a lot to all of you guys for all the investigations you did. Some of them are very useful.
Last week I ordered a MyDel BS1105 antenna and it arrived today, in the morning. I'll check to see if the problem disappears using this external antenna. I've contacted an other RB user from Romania (it is very difficult to find one here :) ) and we will do some 'parallel' tests on weekend. First test will be done near the airport, for the low flying airplanes. In the other test we will target the cruising airplanes.

Now please let me answer to some of you to amplify/eliminate some clues:

I reckon if you place the antenna on its side, you'll get uninterupted coverage over the top, but you won't get much range(well you might, but it will be perpendicular to the axis of the antenna)

As far as I recall I already tried that. While having a plane right over my head, I've placed the antenna parallel to the earth. Still no result :(


I can see the planes visually they dont show up within a 10 miles radius on my radar box.

What kind of antenna you've been using when you saw this behavior? Was the supplied antenna? Thanks.

I tried an experiment, swapping the external antenna for a magmount for the ANRB.

I used my SBS-1e magmount as I've misplaced the ANRB one.

Not conclusive, but I wish I had an ANRB magmount to try.

Thank you very much for this accurate test. That could be a clue. So I should conclude that maybe SBS1 has a better sensibility than RB?

While I agree that antennae may have a blind spot right above them this would not be an issue for this kind of traffic.

This is my opinion too. More than that: I still cannot see the airplane on the map even if it's located aside from my RB's antenna (talking about the low level flights). Probably there's something wrong with my device when it has to decode high power squiters containing 112 bits DF17 message.

Regards.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 15, 2009, 09:13:06 AM
I have the same problem.  I am elevated 180 mtrs asl and my null zone is 68 nm radius.  I have just received my box back from UK for repairs under warranty.  The invoice stated a new board was fitted and all was working A1.  But the problem is exactly the same. 
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Allocator on November 15, 2009, 09:21:32 AM
I've never seen this problem and I'm at a loss to see how it can happen.  I can understand a loss of range, either due to an antenna problem or a RB hardware problem, but to loose contacts in the overhead out to 68nm - I have no idea.

Are you seeing aircraft disappear into this 'overhead' and if so, at what height?  Is there any pattern to what you are seeing in height/distance?

Why not set the aircraft trails to maximum in Preferences - Seconds to Remove Trails - and post a screen shot here to give us a better idea of the problem.

The maximum is 10000 seconds - I just enter 999999 and hit apply.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Allocator on November 15, 2009, 09:29:03 AM
Just did a quick test with my box - no problems with the overhead at all.  TOM38B about 2 miles east  of the overhead climbing through FL170 and RYR8274 about 10 miles west at FL300.

Are you sure that you haven't got any filters selected?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 15, 2009, 09:45:38 AM
No filters selected, it happens on 2 different computers with fresh installs.  I have a high gain home made antenna and supplied antenna is same. 
It works ok out to 260 nm, when the a/c reach 68 nm they dissapear from the map, but remain in the list as mode-s and continue to be updated. When going past and reaching 68 nm the opposite side they reappear on the map. 
I have my own theory about this.  I think the RB has a problem with multiple path signals (ADS-B only)  ie signals direct from the a/c and up reflected from the ground.  Once the a/c approaches a certain distance I receive these multi signals,  most of my signals are across water which is where it is worst
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Allocator on November 15, 2009, 10:22:01 AM
I think that if RB had a problem with 'multiple path signals' - although I'm not quite sure what you mean by this really - then it would be a common problem seen by loads of people.  I run my RB in a number of different areas, from the very busy London area with an incredible number of aircraft, to areas where the majority of traffic is medium to high level.  The results are the same - no blind area in the overhead.

I'm sure I remember a problem with a user in Singapore(?) who wasn't picking up local traffic.  I can't remember what the ideas were that were put forward for this, but it is a very unusual occurrence.

Have you tried running your RB from a different location?

That exact figure of 68 miles worries me a bit - why would it be exactly that figure?  What sort of level are the aircraft?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 15, 2009, 10:31:38 AM
Yes it is very strange and annoying.  I havnt yet tried it at a diff location, I will take it mobile with a laptop when I get a chance.   With multiple path signals they can cancell out each other, or interfere with each other.  I am only guessing as I have no other explanation. 
FYI   I also have a SBS1e and it has none of these problems which would eliminate an interference at this location
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Allocator on November 15, 2009, 10:47:14 AM
OK, we will wait with interest.  Oh, by the way, welcome to the forum as I see that you are a new member.  Have you only just discovered the forum?

I've got an SBS-1 too, and I ran RB and the SBS side by side for quite a while as I'd already had the SBS-1 for a year when I got my RB.  Two and a half years on and I don't use the SBS at all now.  I will fire it up again if Kinetic ever produce a software upgrade - lol

I didn't have any issues with a blind area with the SBS-1 either - the performance of the 2 boxes was pretty much identical, except of course for the RB network.

Where about in the world are you?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: radarspotter10 on November 15, 2009, 11:28:29 AM
OK, we will wait with interest.  Oh, by the way, welcome to the forum as I see that you are a new member.  Have you only just discovered the forum?

I've got an SBS-1 too, and I ran RB and the SBS side by side for quite a while as I'd already had the SBS-1 for a year when I got my RB.  Two and a half years on and I don't use the SBS at all now.  I will fire it up again if Kinetic ever produce a software upgrade - lol

I didn't have any issues with a blind area with the SBS-1 either - the performance of the 2 boxes was pretty much identical, except of course for the RB network.

Where about in the world are you?


Hi Allocator.
Same this side allocator working perfect, maybe aerial on aircraft vertical/horizontal ? i dont know,  and welcome Mike_Tassy to the forum.
Mike_Tassy my problem at the minute on this forum, and not referring to you,
but i notice new members with a mission to run airnav down on there first or second posts, i have reported this to airnav, and airnav have caught a few in the last week.
Airnav is your product that good that people have to come to disrupt this forum and try to discredit the airnav system ?.
from pat 
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 15, 2009, 11:44:15 AM
Hi I am in Tasmania, Australia and not running any products down, just telling it like it is, and just need a fix for this problem. I really prefer the Airnav product aspecially the software side ,I think ANRB is far superior. I also have both boxes and find the performance to be similar - except the null.   You can rule out anything to do with antennas, coax,  computers, location, interference it just comes down to the box itself
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Allocator on November 15, 2009, 11:46:09 AM
Any chance of a screen shot Mike?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 15, 2009, 11:48:59 AM
I will fire the ANRB up and connect to the network for a coup[le of days, you can see the problem for yourself.  I am at  S41 04.00  /  E145 53.00   NW Tasmania
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: radarspotter10 on November 15, 2009, 12:03:37 PM


Sent you pm .mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 15, 2009, 12:10:25 PM
I have just set the network up will leave it running for a couple of days,  it is almost midnite here so wont be much on for 5 or 6 hours
Any way I can put a label on my QTH which will show on the map
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Allocator on November 15, 2009, 12:15:19 PM
I will fire the ANRB up and connect to the network for a coup[le of days, you can see the problem for yourself.  I am at  S41 04.00  /  E145 53.00   NW Tasmania
Mike

OK, I've marked your home location and will watch on the Network.

And just confirm that you can't see anything inside 68 miles in all directions but you can see aircraft within this area on your SBS-1?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 15, 2009, 12:23:00 PM
correct
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Allocator on November 15, 2009, 01:19:10 PM
Of course, it will be impossible to know if Network traffic showing within 68 miles of your location is being picked up by you or by somebody else.

Do you get much traffic from the south of you?

If you posted a screen shot of your non-network traffic when you see any, then that would help.

Can you see the traffic going east-west over Victoria?  There has been a steady flow and I wonder if this is your traffic being fed to the Network.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 16, 2009, 10:03:57 AM
Hi I have had my network going today and I also have a plot from planeplotter with a few hours worth.  The red circle is where I cannot receive any plots, although the aircraft remain in the list of mode-s and are continually updated, then reappear on the map when going out the opposite direction.   My receive range is good, I can get up to the nsw / vic border most times.
Mike

 
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 16, 2009, 10:57:35 PM
Wasn't there someone in NZ who had a problem like this with a rectangular area near his location?

The fact that both of you are in a similar area of the world makes me wonder if it's some kind of maths error in calculating where the aircraft are displayed.

Do the targets show as having a position? If so, what happens when you double click one of the My Flights entries that isn't showing on the map? I wonder if the map suddenly jumps off elsewhere.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Allocator on November 16, 2009, 11:39:11 PM
That's the best idea so far Brian, and seeing the screen shot from Mike certainly shows the problem he has.  Thanks Mike, a picture being worth a 1,000 words and all that.

Mike, are you seeing the 'globe' marker next to these flights when they are in your 'dark area'?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 17, 2009, 02:07:24 AM

Do the targets show as having a position?


Hi, there is a globe next to the entry in myflights up until it enters my no go zone, the globe dissappears, and the lat / long dissappears from the end of the flight s details.  All the time though, the aircraft is still in myflights and is still being updated with mode-s - just not with lat / long and therefore not on the map.  It all reappears going out the other side. 
There were a couple of posts earlier in this section with people having the same problem, others may have the same problem and dont know it till it is  pointed out.  I wonder how many have just accepted this as "being down to my location" or "just my antenna"

Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 17, 2009, 07:51:51 AM
Hi I have had my network going today and I also have a plot from planeplotter with a few hours worth.  The red circle is where I cannot receive any plots, although the aircraft remain in the list of mode-s and are continually updated, then reappear on the map when going out the opposite direction.   My receive range is good, I can get up to the nsw / vic border most times.

Is it only lat/lon that you lose, or do you stop getting groundspeed and track updates as well?

If the latter, I would suspect that for some reason 112-bit ADS-B packets are being lost, whereas 56-bit Mode S packets are being processed successfully.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: airdata on November 17, 2009, 09:46:20 AM
Hi Folks.  Well yes I had the problem with my radarbox in Auckland, New Zealand.  I recently sent it back and today I got it back.  A note mentioned that a new circuitboard was soldered in.  It is however the same original RB unit.  Sadly, the problem that I have of a very large rectangular area with no coverage remains.  My topic was here: http://www.airnavsystems.com/forum/index.php?topic=3452.0

So this issue remains.  The symptoms are the same as posted in this thread.

Any ideas??
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 17, 2009, 10:33:01 AM
Hi David, I only lose lat/long from the aircraft in Myflights.  When you scroll across to the end of the aircraft, everything is there except lat/long.   I watched a flight today taking particular note of this.  When the lat/long dissapears from the list it drops off the map and the globe dissapears. Its as if it loses the ADS-B part of the messages but the mode-s is still populated for the entire flight
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: bratters on November 17, 2009, 10:42:49 AM
Hi David, I only lose lat/long from the aircraft in Myflights.  When you scroll across to the end of the aircraft, everything is there except lat/long.   I watched a flight today taking particular note of this.  When the lat/long dissapears from the list it drops off the map and the globe dissapears. Its as if it loses the ADS-B part of the messages but the mode-s is still populated for the entire flight
Mike

A break in postional data sounds more like transmission interruption than reception problem?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 17, 2009, 10:57:43 AM
Hi David, I only lose lat/long from the aircraft in Myflights.  When you scroll across to the end of the aircraft, everything is there except lat/long.   I watched a flight today taking particular note of this.  When the lat/long dissapears from the list it drops off the map and the globe dissapears. Its as if it loses the ADS-B part of the messages but the mode-s is still populated for the entire flight

Hmm, so you are saying that *only* lat/long disappears, if you still have GS and heading then the 112 bit packets are being received.

Can you capture some port 30003 output? Telnet should do it, then you can paste a bit here and no doubt Dave Reid can pronounce.

There is also a way of capturing the USB data, Google for USB Logger, it's freeware. That should then be definitive as to whether the correct bit pattern is received, each bit comes over USB as a byte where the bits are 8MHz samples with 00001111 and 11110000 as representations of the possible uncorrupted data bits.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 17, 2009, 11:03:25 AM
Hi David, I only lose lat/long from the aircraft in Myflights.  When you scroll across to the end of the aircraft, everything is there except lat/long.

OK - but does the track and GS still change after you lose the lat/lon, or are they stuck at the last received values?

If it's only lat/lon and not track/GS that stops being updated, then I would strongly suspect an encoding/decoding bug. 

There is no reason that I can see for 112-bit Airborne Position squitters being lost while 112-bit Airborne Velocity squitters are still being received.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 17, 2009, 12:31:26 PM
Hi David, yes track alt and GS still populate, its only lat/long that is lost.
I have takenmy ANRB out of line for a bit , am using my SBS-1e for a while. Will put it back on line later
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 17, 2009, 12:33:20 PM
"Can you capture some port 30003 output? Telnet should do it, then you can paste a bit here and no doubt Dave Reid can pronounce."

Ok will get onto it
Cheers bed time for me
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Jeremy on November 17, 2009, 03:57:53 PM
I still wonder if I have a 'null area' which I have discussed before. If you look at the attached screen shot you can see MyFlights to the West and around London approaching Heathrow. The network is seeing the a/c on the ground at Heathrow but there are only 2 a/c in the straight line approach from the east. Even though the timeout is only 10 secs from live to realtime, there seems to be a period where direct signal is the same value as what the network is sending, so nothing gets displayed.  The network coverage around London should should show more. Just a theory.
J.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 17, 2009, 04:00:53 PM
there seems to be a period where direct signal is the same value as what the network is sending, so nothing gets displayed.  The network coverage around London should should show more. Just a theory.

Easily tested, of course, by turning the network off and seeing if the problems persists.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: tarbat on November 17, 2009, 04:01:28 PM
I still wonder if I have a 'null area' which I have discussed before.

One way to check is to run OverFlightLogger.  WIll give you a complete coverage map by flight level - here's mine as an example - http://www.tarbat.gofreeserve.com/polar.htm
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Support on November 17, 2009, 04:11:56 PM
there seems to be a period where direct signal is the same value as what the network is sending, so nothing gets displayed.  The network coverage around London should should show more. Just a theory.

Easily tested, of course, by turning the network off and seeing if the problems persists.

The network value would only be "fresh" for that one second after its downloaded. After which any other message you get from your box will be used.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Jeremy on November 17, 2009, 05:30:09 PM
Well there is a revelation.
Airnav - Please look at the 2 screen shots.
They are less than 1 minute apart the second having unchecked 'Process Hardware Flights.
Up pop a load of a/c on the Heathrow flight path.
Any comments gratefully received.
J.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Support on November 17, 2009, 05:40:51 PM
Jeremy,

Where is your home location on that map? If you don't want broadcast it PM us, as it seems you are getting network flights for low altitude flights which means you don't have them in line of sight fully.

The issue your showing is nothing to do with the issues mentioned from people in New Zealand and Australia. In your case Jeremy you may be getting a weak signal from those aircraft but only Mode-S, these messages are then blocking out the network aircraft as your receiving from them locally.

We can fine tune the settings of aircraft going from local to network flights but it’s sometimes not an easy item as some aircraft might go back and forth out of range.
 
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 17, 2009, 06:15:08 PM
His forum profile reveals his home location Airnav....
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Support on November 17, 2009, 06:19:59 PM
Thanks Fenris.

That would mean the aircraft lined up on the ILS would be hard to see from his location unless his antenna has a clear view. Though not impossible hence the smaller Mode-S signals get through.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 17, 2009, 06:22:36 PM
Yes, I presume that a few odd frames received will lock out the network data for that aircraft. Probably needs to adjust the timeouts to shorten those for local flights some more.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Support on November 17, 2009, 06:24:23 PM
Agreed, though its not related to the issues from the other side of the world.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 17, 2009, 06:26:05 PM
No, indeed. Separate problems.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Jeremy on November 17, 2009, 09:18:24 PM
Airnav and Fenris.
Thanks for your help. AN we have discussed this before about a year ago but my slow machine was thought to be the trouble. My location is Newbury, just showing to the west of the screen shot. This problem is actually hitting me quite hard as I am losing I guess about 40% of traffic when allowing my hardware to interfere.
Can you make a recommendation as to the correct timeouts. MyF is set to 10 and 10 secs.
J.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 18, 2009, 09:44:11 AM
"Can you capture some port 30003 output? Telnet should do it, then you can paste a bit here and no doubt Dave Reid can pronounce."

Hi can someone step me through how to do this, I guess you use Hyperterminal.

I tried a USB Capture program but my low spec laptop cant handle both programs .
If anyone is interested I recorded a couple of track passes through my no go zone, I can send if needed  (600k)
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 18, 2009, 12:23:47 PM
The Windows telnet program should do the job Mike, but it may not be installed by default. Which OS are you running?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 18, 2009, 12:28:57 PM
Windows xp    -  has hyperterminal standard  -  also telnet.exe
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 18, 2009, 12:37:01 PM
OK, I think telnet to port 30003 or 7879 will work, then you need to capture the data to a file.

I suppose it would help if you indicate the aircraft that initially appear on the map, and that then disappear. That will make it easier to spot them in the XML stream.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 18, 2009, 12:41:16 PM
How do I telnet to port 30003?   
Then capture the received data using select all / copy paste??

Think I see- "open 30003"

Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 18, 2009, 12:45:58 PM
If you open a command prompt, type:

telnet localhost 30003

and you should see data (after 5 minutes if using a 3.0x beta version).

I think you can do cut and paste, it's possible it also works if you use the:

> <filename>

syntax in the command.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 18, 2009, 12:49:57 PM
Thanks got it
Will do a capture tomorrow, midnite here no traffic
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: shouriken on November 18, 2009, 01:01:46 PM
In order to save the telnet session into a file the syntax is:

telnet -f C:\rb.txt localhost 30003

The capture file will be C:\rb.txt. Replace the path wit whatever you prefer.

Liviu
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 18, 2009, 10:31:22 PM
Hi I am able to connect to 30003 and see data stream with telnet,  how do I capture to a file.  I will get to it when I get home from work this arvo
Mike

Sorry just saw the previous post
Thanks
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 19, 2009, 07:06:30 AM
I have a capture from today, how should I send it? Can I attach as a file to a post
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 19, 2009, 07:34:04 AM
I have a capture from today, how should I send it? Can I attach as a file to a post

I don't see why not - people attach fairly massive images to some of their posts, so size shouldn't be a problem (but Zip it first!).
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 19, 2009, 08:09:21 AM
Hi The aircraft in question is TGW572  -  VH-VNF  -  7C6C29

It passed through my no go zone at time 17.37.35

Attached is a txt file

Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: tarbat on November 19, 2009, 08:46:01 AM
Hi I am able to connect to 30003 and see data stream with telnet,  how do I capture to a file.

Probably easiest thing is to use SBSSIM.  This will let you capture port 30003 output to a file.

[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 19, 2009, 09:34:24 AM
Hi The aircraft in question is TGW572  -  VH-VNF  -  7C6C29

It passed through my no go zone at time 17.37.35

Attached is a txt file

OK - I have good news and bad news.

First the good news, you aren't losing the signals from aircraft above you - they are still being received, so there's nothing wrong with your RadarBox hardware or aerial.

Now the bad news, there is a position encoding/decoding bug which means that aircraft latitudes and longitudes aren't being shown correctly.  My money is on a decoding bug in RB, simply because if it were an encoding bug on board the aircraft I think we'd have heard about it before now (it affects several aircraft in your sample, not just VH-VNF, and not all the time either).

What is happening is that, at a certain point in their trajectory, RadarBox starts outputting longitudes with a minus 360 degree offset so that, for example 146 degrees E (+146) becomes minus 214 degrees W (-214).  Obviously that means the resulting position can't be plotted on the map, so the aircraft symbol disappears from your screen.

I have no doubt that AirNav Development and Support are monitoring this thread too, so we'll leave it in their capable hands.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Support on November 19, 2009, 09:37:50 AM
We will investigate.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 19, 2009, 09:43:06 AM
We will investigate.

I'll send you my bill for the diagnosis  :-)
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: OKC-Steve on November 19, 2009, 10:11:55 AM
Looking at the Socket Output, it is not compatible with the SBS-1 either.  The last four numbers should be 0,0,0,0 as default (for false) and -1 if any of them are true.

The decoding code should probably issue an exception if lat or lon are unmappable.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: tarbat on November 19, 2009, 10:22:21 AM
Might this be connected to the blind rectangle near New Zealand?  I suggested a possible decoding error for that problem, but I don't think it got pursued any further.

http://www.airnavsystems.com/forum/index.php?topic=3452.msg33227#msg33227
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: OKC-Steve on November 19, 2009, 10:29:44 AM
Might this be connected to the blind rectangle near New Zealand?  I suggested a possible decoding error for that problem, but I don't think it got pursued any further.

http://www.airnavsystems.com/forum/index.php?topic=3452.msg33227#msg33227

I think you're right.  Looks like his trouble ticket got abandoned.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 19, 2009, 11:18:13 AM
Well, it's good news that it has been identified and it's a software problem. They are easier to fix than hardware problems, especially ones common to all shipped hardware.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Support on November 19, 2009, 12:11:21 PM
Nothing has been confirmed yet. Let us fully investigate all the details.

We did conduct similar tests as Dave has done on an customer in India who mentioned similar results earlier this year however we didn't find a software or hardware issue.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 19, 2009, 12:14:56 PM
Looking at the Socket Output, it is not compatible with the SBS-1 either.  The last four numbers should be 0,0,0,0 as default (for false) and -1 if any of them are true.

The decoding code should probably issue an exception if lat or lon are unmappable.


By this do you mean the SBS will have the same problem??
I have the SBS1-e and it doesnt suffer from this
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 19, 2009, 12:20:36 PM
Might this be connected to the blind rectangle near New Zealand?  I suggested a possible decoding error for that problem, but I don't think it got pursued any further.

http://www.airnavsystems.com/forum/index.php?topic=3452.msg33227#msg33227

Ahem !  As did I, two posts prior to yours !  :-)
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 19, 2009, 12:22:57 PM
 "(it affects several aircraft in your sample, not just VH-VNF, and not all the time either)."

I notice the ANRB does lose some position plots in other areas as well, they just seem to drop in and out, where the SBS does not.  Hope it can be fixed and thanks for the help as I really like the ANRB software, and I will only keep one box, sell the other off
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: OKC-Steve on November 19, 2009, 12:59:44 PM
By this do you mean the SBS will have the same problem??

I guess I don't understand your question. Nothing described here will affect another product.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 19, 2009, 03:41:10 PM
Nothing has been confirmed yet. Let us fully investigate all the details.

I only meant that if the software is outputting longitude numbers that are less than -180 degrees (i.e. -214 degrees as mentioned) then it has to be a calculation error.

Either that or the world has been turned into a Klein bottle.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: shouriken on November 19, 2009, 04:00:55 PM
I will paste a small part of a logged flight:

MSG,1,0,0,4A0663,0,2009.11.19,17:34:48.453,2009.11.19,17:39:48.453,ROT373,,,,,,,,,,,
MSG,3,0,0,4A0663,0,2009.11.19,17:34:48.453,2009.11.19,17:39:48.453,,1900,,,44.5867,-333.8703,,,,,,

MSG,3,0,0,4A0663,0,2009.11.19,17:39:44.156,2009.11.19,17:44:44.156,,13925,,,44.7476,-334.2863,,,,,,
MSG,3,0,0,4A0663,0,2009.11.19,17:39:44.156,2009.11.19,17:44:44.156,,13950,,,44.7480,25.7127,,,,,,

The flight started to get tracked in ANRB at 17:39:45 ( local time) when the longitude became 25.7127
Notice that 360-334.2863=25.7137

Liviu
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: tarbat on November 19, 2009, 04:17:41 PM
This looks like it might be location specific.

I left SBSSIM recording all port 30003 output today.  Imported into Excel, sorted by LAT and then by LONG, and all lat/long values are valid, in the range:
LAT : 54.7957 to 58.9588
LONG: -8.2794 to +0.6318
That's out of 112,000 lines of port 30003 output.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 19, 2009, 04:37:16 PM
Yes, and I'm certain that the ADS-B frame doesn't allow for greater than 180 or less than -180 degrees of longitude, so it was not transmitted like that.

This is almost certainly location specific Tarbat, if it weren't then it would have been found and fixed some time ago as the level of complaints would be much higher. It may be a combination of home location and aircraft position.

If the person concerned is the only sharer on the network, I wonder where these aircraft would show up? Possibly the server rejects them as being in impossible places ;-)


Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 19, 2009, 06:15:26 PM
Yes, and I'm certain that the ADS-B frame doesn't allow for greater than 180 or less than -180 degrees of longitude, so it was not transmitted like that.

Indeed not, although latitude and longitude aren't sent explicitly - instead, they are encoded using the CPR algorithm based on 360nm cells, and decoding is by no means a trivial exercise so it's quite conceivable that a bug has crept into the process.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Development on November 19, 2009, 07:56:24 PM
We would ask all users reporting this problem to send us a PM so we can contact them directly with a new exe ready for testing.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: OKC-Steve on November 19, 2009, 08:02:51 PM
Don't forget to fix the socket output as well:  The last 4 values are boolean, so they must be either 0 or -1, and not null.

FYI
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 19, 2009, 08:06:25 PM
Well, shouriken and Mike_Tassy are two of them, and it could be the reason for the problem described by the guy in NZ who had a blank rectangle near his home location, I can't remember his forum ID.

Do you want any other people to test it too?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Development on November 19, 2009, 08:08:03 PM
We've just Pm'ed them. Waiting for their replies.

This thread clearly shows how this forum is helpful and positive: a typical example on how users in direct contact with a company development can result in positive news for both sides.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 19, 2009, 08:15:36 PM
airdata is the forum ID of the NZ guy with the blank rectangle.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 19, 2009, 08:16:27 PM
The NZ and Aus people should be waking up about now too.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 19, 2009, 08:19:36 PM
vic_atc is anothe forum member with a problem of this nature
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 19, 2009, 11:46:19 PM
We would ask all users reporting this problem to send us a PM so we can contact them directly with a new exe ready for testing.

Presumably if affected users are sharing, you will be able to pick up invalid coordinate data on the network ?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Development on November 19, 2009, 11:49:03 PM
Dave: tks for your message. We've sent a PM to 3 of these users. We are just waiting for tehir replies. We are 99% sure the problem is now corrected. Just waiting for their feedback.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 20, 2009, 01:49:53 AM
Hi sent  A PM TO Andre, waiting for a reply.  I am home for lunch will probably check back later this arvo  - oh and I am excited at the prospect of this being fixed
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 20, 2009, 01:51:34 AM
Meanwhile I will put my ANRB online for a while
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 20, 2009, 04:07:15 AM
Just downloaded the new exe  will report back with my findings
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 20, 2009, 04:22:23 AM
Hmmm the first test is not good, no change.
Just tracked a flight from YMLT Launceston to YMML Melbourne and lost the tracking at the same place as before
Sorry guys
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: vic_atc on November 20, 2009, 08:22:06 AM
Hi all,

On this Saturday, me and Shouriken will perform some tests around LROP airport with our RBs. As I mentioned before, besides the high altitude flights problem, I've also noticed a problem for the app/dep airplanes around LROP airport. Hope this has also something to do with the "blind rectangle". Probabily, the LROP's neighborhood forms such a rectangle. I didn't have time to test the port 30003 output (to see the +/- 360 deg problem) but I'll do that in this weekend (for the both problems: high altitude flights and LROP's app/dep flights).

Thanks to all of you for the investigations!

Victor
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Gregg on November 21, 2009, 10:46:31 AM
Hi, thinking about buying the radar box, if after 1 years free network , i decide not to subscribe further , will this stop me getting updates i.e. registrations of new aircraft etc.If not on the network how wud this be obtained.Also i have purchase the ACARS program, 12 mths ago, without even using it yet, is it possible to run ACARS and Radar box together

Gregg
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Gregg on November 21, 2009, 10:47:28 AM
oops sry just noticed ive posted this to a existing thread apologies 

Gregg
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 21, 2009, 11:11:50 AM
Gregg in short everything except nework sharing of aircraft will work after initial 12 months.
Only sharing data wont work
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: radarspotter10 on November 21, 2009, 03:17:22 PM
Hmmm the first test is not good, no change.
Just tracked a flight from YMLT Launceston to YMML Melbourne and lost the tracking at the same place as before
Sorry guys
Mike
hi mike.
I hope airnav can get you sorted out soon, and we can get the new software,
but if you think about it MIKE look at the support you are getting unbelievable.
I think its a great credit to airnav for the support they give us all.
from pat
 
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: OKC-Steve on November 21, 2009, 04:45:04 PM
All I can say, is at the speed you guys are troubleshooting this, you should be done by the time we all head to Mecca in the spring...
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 21, 2009, 11:08:21 PM
Thanks Pat, yes they have been very helpful, I am in contact via email with Andre, have sent him some recordings and port 30003 captures , hope they can fix this soon.
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 21, 2009, 11:17:32 PM
The problem is that the encoding algorithm, and hence the decoding algorithm, are fairly nasty and complex. It also seems there is something to do with the location of the user, but maybe that's just because of where the aircraft are expected to plot.

It's only recently that there have been enough users in SE Asia, Australasia and NZ for this to have become noticeable.

But a test suite for the program would be really useful for catching odd bugs by feeding systematic data into the decoder and checking what it outputs against known correct data.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 21, 2009, 11:33:03 PM
The problem is that the encoding algorithm, and hence the decoding algorithm, are fairly nasty and complex.

The problem isn't that the decoding algorithm is complex - it's that it hasn't been implemented properly !
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 21, 2009, 11:39:59 PM
One reason for which is that it is complex, and the corner cases have not been checked properly.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: airdata on November 22, 2009, 01:27:33 AM
Hi airnav.  I am more than happy to assist with the testing of the updated software as I have had my mysterious large rectangle of nil coverage from day 1.  Feel free to contact me if you would like me to test out the updated software.  Regards  Mark
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Development on November 22, 2009, 02:21:56 AM
We are still working on the blind rectangle problem. We sent a new .exe to 5 different users a few minutes ago (airdata, you are included) and we are waiting for their feedback.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Development on November 22, 2009, 03:57:53 AM
Problem corrected (as confirmed by users in Australia and NZ). One step closer to V3.1 final release!
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Mike_Tassy on November 22, 2009, 05:13:10 AM
My first test of approaching aircraft from north reveals...NO DROPOUTS
Seems the problem mite be fixed
Mike
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: OKC-Steve on November 22, 2009, 05:43:53 AM
If it's not too embarrasing, maybe you can share the solution.  Some of us are interested in the CPR technical challenges.  I'm writing a decoder myself, and it is an interesting concept for sure.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: shouriken on November 22, 2009, 06:57:32 AM
Looks good for me too.
First time I see take-off's from LROP :D

Thank you AirNav

Liviu
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: pjm on November 22, 2009, 08:52:37 AM
Problem corrected (as confirmed by users in Australia and NZ).

And working very well - after a few hours running you can already see far more coverage in the previous blackholes. Pink shows the new coverage so far :)

(http://img22.imageshack.us/img22/1949/20091122194803.jpg) (http://img22.imageshack.us/img22/1949/20091122194803.jpg)
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: airdata on November 22, 2009, 09:24:45 AM
Nice to see that this problem has finally been resolved.  Coverage around Auckland has increased markedly.  In some areas range has increased by 60nm.  The polar diagram is taking on a whole new look.  All I need now is a few more aeroplanes!!

One small bug I got is the software swapping tags (route and flight ID) for 2 aircraft in the air at the same time with hex codes one digit apart.  This happened twice this evening with C81882 & C81883, and also with C81B14 & C81B15.  In both cases, the same flight ID and route was shown for both aircraft until one aircraft dropped off when the second aircraft's information corrected itself.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: gleff on November 22, 2009, 09:59:22 AM
I have the following polar diagram.  Is this bug fix likely to improve it, or is it only in certain circumstances?  Or perhaps would a mast head amplifier kit improve things.  My antenna is located on my balcony railing on the 13th floor of my apartment building.  It faces other buildings though.  As you can see i've been able to reach approx. 400 kilometers away down south, and also a fair way west, but I don't have much distance out to sea or north.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: pjm on November 22, 2009, 10:32:27 AM
I have the following polar diagram.  Is this bug fix likely to improve it, or is it only in certain circumstances?

My understanding of the blackholes around Sydney are/were approx here:
(http://img217.imageshack.us/img217/5884/20091122212521.jpg)

So if you were seeing the aircraft disappear from your radar screen in the area towards Canberra in the bottom right of square, then likely you will see them all the way to Canberra with the new software.

Or perhaps would a mast head amplifier kit improve things.  My antenna is located on my balcony railing on the 13th floor of my apartment building.

I'd suggest its unlikely, I have bought 2 thinking the first was faulty, and I get less coverage with the pre-amp on. Although I have no proof, I think the preamp may be overloading the front end of my RB. I have 10m of low loss coax to an external antenna.

My guess is your run would be too short (like mine) for a preamp to make any positive difference.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: gleff on November 22, 2009, 10:37:42 AM
I guess i'll just have to wait and see then.. I'm not sure if i've had aircraft drop off the display since it happens a fair bit anywhere. 

Thanks for the info though..
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 22, 2009, 01:01:39 PM
Problem corrected (as confirmed by users in Australia and NZ). One step closer to V3.1 final release!

Good to hear that. Are you able to indicate what other things are being worked on? Purely for interest....
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: tarbat on November 22, 2009, 01:41:53 PM
Good to hear that. Are you able to indicate what other things are being worked on? Purely for interest....

AFAIK, the other issue being worked on at the moment is spikes in the polar chart possibly caused by the real-time network.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: bratters on November 22, 2009, 02:02:45 PM

AFAIK, the other issue being worked on at the moment is spikes in the polar chart possibly caused by the real-time network.

Interesting that Tarbat.  I notice that sometimes when I close Network - not realtime but 5min. delayed - one or more flights can still be seen outside, though generally close to, a polar diagram spike. These will appear in MyFlights but do respond to the cursor.
 
They disappear after a short while but there is no doubt that an occasional overlap/connection occurs between Network andMYFlights.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: DaveReid on November 22, 2009, 02:05:14 PM
Good to hear that. Are you able to indicate what other things are being worked on? Purely for interest....

AFAIK, the other issue being worked on at the moment is spikes in the polar chart possibly caused by the real-time network.

Hopefully issues in the plural - the widely-reported duplicate details (for similar hex codes) is on the list as well, I believe.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 22, 2009, 02:37:45 PM
Pleased to hear about all that.

I still see the polar diagram fail to clear up its previously constructed lines in some cases, it's a minor thing but it never happened in v2.01 so it's a regression in my book.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: OKC-Steve on November 22, 2009, 03:04:10 PM
Did they fix the 30003 socket booleans? or did they leave them nulls still?
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: Fenris on November 22, 2009, 03:19:51 PM
No idea. Perhaps Airnav can comment when they get a chance, it will be to their benefit to fix all the things that are known about.
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: AirNav Development on November 22, 2009, 03:35:22 PM
Just PMed OKC-Steve
Title: Re: Radarbox is "blind" for the planes above my head
Post by: vic_atc on November 22, 2009, 07:27:33 PM
Also worked for me! Great job, Airnav!

Thank you! And my best regards.